Monday, September 8, 2008

Dream, Build, Play

AKA: Dream, dream, and dream some more.

Microsoft has set out to, as they say, "democratize" the game industry with XNA.

For those of you who have not heard of XNA (and are too lazy to look it up) here are some helpful links: Gamasutra feature and Official Page. You will also find many references to it in past blog posts, as Matt and I have used it extensively and have even made some video tutorials on it: Blog Post or Download Page.

The idea is to give the power to make games to mere mortals. No longer will games only be produced by huge teams and EA's sweatshops, but by anyone with the with determination and a little bit of know how. XNA (you don't want to know what the acronym stands for) allows you to write games in C# that can then be played on both windows machines and the XBOX360. And other than the account required to play the games on your XBOX, it's all free! And if you sign up for Dream Build Play, you can get a four month Creators Club account free too.

So instead of having to learn C++, one can start of with managed C#, which is much easier to learn. As far as the amateur programmer is concerned, there are no make files or pointers or any of that other confusing C++ stuff. I originally learned how to program in Java, and I must say, the transition was quite smooth.

But XNA is more than just a language choice: there are a multitude of included libraries designed to make writing a game easier, and a plethora of examples and tutorials. There are libraries for interacting with a gamepad, doing matrix operations, and collision detection. I really don't know how they could have made making games any simpler.

But... where are all the games? There are some notable examples, such as some of the previous Dream Build Play competition winners (XBOX.com news), but I haven't really seen a major explosion of indie games. Maybe I haven't given it enough time, and maybe my expectations are too high, but so far the most Dream Build Play has done for me is taught me that "democratize" is actually a real word (I though for sure they had made it up!). I was hoping for a resurgence of the maverick game makers, a new John Carmack or Richard Garriott to show those big game publishers that we don't need them! If a kid gets sick of WWII shooter 12 and thinks he can do better, than gosh darn it he can! All it takes is some dedication and a spot of help from XNA.

But the industry has changed to much, and the best we seem to be able to do with XNA is make some slick looking arcade-style or casual games. Even so, and please correct me if I'm misinformed, we haven't seen an explosion of these games either. XBOX Live has had some successful arcade games (such as geometry wars and Matt mentioned "Braid") but we have yet to see a gaming revolution. I don't see people buying XBOX 360s just so they can play these games, and I definitely don't see "democratized" game making. But what can I expect? After all, a democracy depends on the involvement of it's people, and I certainly haven't done my part.

Which brings me back to the start of this post: despite being interested in games and even making some with XNA (such as the demo one Matt and I made for the video tutorials), I have yet to make a concerted effort to enter in the Dream Build Play competition. I have plenty of ideas and was really excited about this iteration of the competition, but now the deadline is looming and I have nothing to submit. I've got the "dream" part down, but have yet to execute on the "build."

Well, I think it's time for that to change. Although it's a bit late for this competition...

Monday, September 1, 2008

Steam

Let me start this post by saying that I love the idea behind Steam, Valve's gaming platform (http://www.steampowered.com/v/index.php). Being able to buy a game, download it, and then have it automatically update seems like such a great idea that I find it hard to believe that it's not more popular. With a high speed connection, it's ridiculous that one would have to drive all the way to a store to buy a game! Just download and play! So easy and convenient! Sign me up!

And I did sign up, I bought a few games through Steam, and I must admit, I was loving it. I could browse the store, try out demos, and I knew that if I ever bought a new computer, I could just re-download all of the games without the hassle of trying to find those long lost cd keys. Not to mention not having to pop a disk in to my pc every time I wanted to play a game (what is this, a console?).

Unfortunately my early optimism has been steam rolled by a horrible UI, debilitating DRM, poor network connectivity, and resource hog. Not to mention the fact that I am no longer able to play Team Fortress 2.

Steam can take a long time to load, and has increased my windows start time. That bugs me. It also does not work on networks with a DMZ. That bugs my room mate, who is kind enough to switch the option off (thus making his self-hosted site inaccessible when I want to play a game). For some reason, Steam still does not work on my network, and the UI gives no indication as to why, or even that a problem exists. This drives me nuts, because I don't even have an error number to start looking for help with. Finally, I can't play TF2, which downright infuriates me because I paid for the game.

Well, I might be able to play... I hit the launch button about an hour ago, and it appears that the game is finally updating. Finally. Two weeks ago I decided I wanted to see what was new in the Heavy update, and since then it has been an ordeal trying to update steam and get it to run a game. Although the whole time Steam was able to keep me updated on when all of my friends where online playing. GAH!

And when you get down to, all the convenience that is potentially gained by this content delivery system has been totally obliterated by the all of the problems I have run into. I like the idea, but thus far the implementation has left a lot to be desired.

Monday, August 25, 2008

You would if you had robot ears.

Many people have heard of Jonathan Coulton, the artist who wrote "Still Alive" for Portal, as well as the famous "Code Monkey." A hilarious singer / songwriter who isn't afraid to write songs related to computer science, he also has a pretty sweet take on music piracy (see the "Already Stole It?" section on his site: http://www.jonathancoulton.com/store/downloads/).

But Jonathan isn't the only one representing for computer science. Take a look at Monzy's "So Much Drama in the PhD: http://www.monzy.com/intro/drama_lyrics.html. With lyrics like:
Your mom circulates like a public key,
Servicing more requests than HTTP.
She keeps all her ports open like Windows ME,
Oh, there's so much drama in the PhD.
How can one not love his music? Okay, so I've only listened to that one song, but I really didn't feel like hunting through his blog to find more. Really, why do some people feel the need to write irrelevant blogs than no one even reads? His last post had a measly eight comments for crying out loud.

If you listen to his song, you may catch wind of a bit of a rap war between Monzy and a MC++ (http://www.mcplusplus.com/). Well, I have some good news and some bad news. The good news, MC++ has two albums for free download on his site, and I can say with confidence that it is the best hardcore gangsta rap that has ever been made about coding. Ever. The bad news is that the rap war is over, and MC++ has no one to battle.

Except Max Flow, the AI program that he writes for the specific purpose of rap battling! You really need to check these songs out, there are hilarious and of amazingly high quality. These guys don't mess around. The lyrics are smart, and it takes a few sessions to get everything that they are saying. For example, "Master and Apprentice" has some biting commentary on the state of hip-hop today buried in there.

So next time your coding and listening to some pounding techno ("Are you afraid of it?" "No, I just don't like techno."), change things up a bit and listening people rap about coding, as you're coding.

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Where did all of the updates go?

As Matt mentioned, we have finally finished our XNA tutorial videos. Matt and I are extremely proud of these videos, and hope that they will be of use to fellow amateur game developers. Each of the videos took hours to produce, from writing the code, filming, editing, and revisions. And that is why we have not been updating this blog.

Actually, that's not true. In our packed schedules we still managed to find time for Rock Band. Thank you Harmonix for bringing us such a genuinely fun and accessible game. I love rocking out, and it's great being able to get all my friends to play, even the non-gamers.

Matt and I graduate in two and a half weeks, at which point we are going to have to change the description of this blog. And hopefully we will have even less time to update it, as we will be employed in the game industry. We'll see.

Sunday, April 20, 2008

SMP is DONE!

Well, all those people who read this blog (are there any?) good news. The tutorials for XNA are finally done. I am mainly posting here in hopes that people Googling for beginner tutorials will find their way here, and can then be passed on to the real site.

XNA Tutorials

Enjoy, and please give us feedback!

Saturday, February 9, 2008

Why I Don't Play Wow Right Now

I played World of Warcraft for nigh on two years straight starting in closed beta, took a break, came back for The Burning Crusade, and then stopped again when summer of 2007 ended. Why? Because, in a manner of speaking, I had already figured out all the patterns in the game.

I should probably rephrase that, but I was trying to tie it to James’s post earlier (he is borrowing my copy of “Theory of Fun”). I have not solved every underlying pattern that WoW has to offer, but I have experienced almost all of them, and they do not change. When you have a persistent online world, and you are expecting that people are going to pay to play in this world, you need to provide them with reasons to continue playing. Now is the time that you point out “but Matt, Blizzard is making another expansion…” and I say, “Yes they are, but I would like to address a point that going into and beyond simply releasing more content.”

Creating alternate characters is the other way, besides simply growing the world, that MMO’s retain players. However, I tend to find playing alts to be tedious most of the time. This is where I tie in the whole pattern issue. I have already played through this part of the world. Many times. Nothing changed. I am doing the same quests for the same people, in order to receive that same loot. What I would like to propose is the idea of a much more dynamic quest system.

In WoW there are two factions, Horde and Alliance, with different races and different starting areas. However, once you get to around level 30 or so, as either faction you end up in the same neutral zones doing the same quests. From 30-60 I did the same quests on my Horde rogue as I did when I was 30-60 on my Alliance priest. The quest giver simply changed race and name.

Obviously generating dynamic quests on the fly is a very tricky issue, considering that the majority of all quests in all role playing games are probably hand written and planned out. As a temporary solution I would also be strongly in favor of simply creating quest trees with different branches. I would be much better to be able to follow one branch in a series of quests, and then if I come back as a different character, I could follow a separate branch for different results.

I think as MMO’s continue to evolve, we will see worlds that are increasingly more dynamic, and this requires increasingly dynamic tools to work properly. Perhaps one of the reasons that we are in what I would call a quest rut is that the NPC’s in WoW don’t “require” anything. The dwarf who sends me off to kill the yetis that took over his cave is not going to actually return to his cave. But what if he did, and the next time I ventured by he needed other materials in order to rebuild. That is the kind of dynamic quest structure that would make me want to roll another character to and continue playing…and paying.

Tuesday, February 5, 2008

GDC, and theories on fun.

GDC is almost upon us, and I'm getting excited, as well I should be. As a gamer and a computer scientist, I can't imagine an event that would combine more of my passions. Well, unless it was a game developer's conference with a rock climbing competition and Mystery Science Theater 3000 playing in the background the entire time. Until the day that dream is realized, I will be content with attending the GDC. Plus, it's in San Fransisco, so I get to visit somewhere new.

I am a bit nervous though, since part of the reason I am going is to try to land a job. Since I don't graduate until May, my resume is a bit sparse. I am lacking the, "Must have shipped two games on X console" each job seems to require, but everyone has to start somewhere. I will be putting the finishing touches on my resume this week, and I guess we will see what happens.

On a slightly unrelated tangent, I have been reading "A Theory of Fun for Game Design" by Raph Koster, and despite how irritating I find the title (for it's casual use of the word "theory," which is a topic that has no relevance to this blog), I am benefiting greatly from reading it. First and foremost, it has got me thinking about things that I had never even thought to think of before. That was an odd sentence, so let me give you an example: I had never thought about what it is that makes games fun.

As I wrote that, I realized just how ridiculous that sounds from someone who is trying to get into Game Design. After all, shouldn't that be all that I am thinking about? It wasn't that I didn't think the topic wasn't important, I just assumed that I already knew. I've played enough games to know what I find fun, but I had not considered why it's fun, or even exactly what it is beyond "winning" and "crushing all those that stand before me."

Koster's book presents the idea that underneath their pretty exteriors, games are all really about patterns, and our brains love patterns. We delight in finding them, and in a game this is what we are doing when we start to win. We have started to recognize the underlying patterns in the game and have learned how to exploit them. I won't go into all the reasons Koster provides because he does a much better job presenting his point of view than I do, but I have to admit, it's got me thinking. I'm not sure how much I agree with him, but the important thing is that I'm now thinking about something that I had taken for granted. And thinking is good.

I hope to follow up on this post with a bit more of my impressions of Koster's book, but that may have to wait until after GDC, when I have a chance to reread it. And speaking of books worthy of a reread, "The Pragmatic Programmer" by Hunt and Thomas is also on that list.